TimeOut: Tweets Blocking Top Commentators

by SBA on March 26, 2010 · 15 comments

Have you ever installed a new plugin that works fine, but soon after you find another widget starts acting up? Well, is the sky blue? After I changed the Topsy Retweet plugin to show tweets as trackback comments,  some strange names appeared on the Top Commentators list! This post talks about what you can do to make the Topsy  and Top Commentators plugins play well together.

image- Darren Lum

Topsy Retweet Button

Recently, the Tweetme plugin stopped working, so I replaced it with Topsy retweet. Topsy creates the icon for readers to retweet your posts. You can also display tweets as trackback comments whenever someone tweets your article. The plugin captures historical tweet counts and is simply perfect!

Not only does the top part of our button display how many times the post has been tweeted, but if you press the number you can see who actually posted the tweets. The software also flags "influential" and highly influential" tweeters!

This snapshot shows three Twitter trackback for a recent post:

Notice 'techandlife' is an influential tweeter who tweeted directly, while 'lanaktng' used AddToAny, and 'mikeeadams' retweeted someone else's RT.

The Influence factor

measures the likelihood that, each time you say something, people will pay attention. ...  roughly the top 0.2% most influential of all Twitter users are tagged “Highly Influential” and  “Influential” tags appear for the top 0.5% ... Topsy Labs

Well I'm not a snobbish person, but I did find a handy way to use the influence labels. I did not want to display 13 or more tweets trackbacks. So I told the plugin to show only 'influential' tweeters by selecting these options:

Trackback Comments

Comment Display Style

Use the second option to show the tweet text --- some themes like Thesis show only a link name.

Top Commentators Widget

We use Webgrrrl's Top Commentators Widget to recognize our most vocal readers with a follow- link.  Of course that means monitoring and squashing the con artists with names like “Mortgage Loans”,  who leave comments just for the linkback. Other 'gamers' try stealing a real top commentator's  identity! The bad guys submit a short comment with the good guy's name, but use their own email and url.

Here's how the widget helps you control some of the gamers: 1) exclude spam commentators who slip though the cracks over time; 2) set a limit on the length of names to shut out the likes of  'highly polished wood floors;' and 3) put in the url for sites with spam mailboxes.

top commentators widget

Solving Problem of Topsy and Commentator Fouls

The solution to the problem of tweet trackbacks hogging our Top Commentators list is to block influential tweeters. Why would I want to do that? Well, if their tweet trackbacks force them to the top of the list. I feel the widget is for readers who take part in the dialog around the blog's content.

The solution is to add the Twitter domain name to the list of users we want to block in the Top Commentators widget:


Do you use the Twitter trackbacks feature of Topsy Retweet? Feel free to start the discussion on this topic.  Who knows, you may make our Top Commentators' list if your name is not "Used Tires"!

4 Reasons For Subscribing
  • Get Full Posts Delivered Directly To Your Inbox.
  • Get Exclusive Freebies For Subscribers.
  • No "Buy This, Buy That" Mails!
  • 100% Privacy. Your EMail Address Will Never Be Shared With Any Third Party.
About Writer [Blogging With Success]About Author SBA is a web designer and co-founder of BloggingWithSuccess. She publishes BPWebNews a place for many Blogspot tips and tricks. You can also find her on Twitter. Read SBA's other posts. She's also published a couple of guest posts.

{ 12 comments }

Mary@making money online August 17, 2011

Thanks for discussion about this twit plugin I was not using it but I would use it for sure.

CT April 10, 2010

I installed the Topsy Retweet Button plugin recently. I initially only wanted a quick-and-easy way to provide inline retweeting, but I've found the Topsy-powered trackbacking of RTs to be the more gratifying aspect of this tool (for me, anyway). I've also hacked the tweet-trackbacks slightly to include a Twitter button-icon when they post to my site, to better ID them as social media "reactions". Here's an example.

SBA April 11, 2010

Nicely done. very interesting website name. Thanks for stopping by.

Whiztechy March 31, 2010

I am using Tweetmeme pluing, I will surely give a try to topsy. I liked the tip to enable on influential people trackbacks. Nice post. :)

SBA March 31, 2010

You'll be glad you did. Let us know. I tweeted one of your posts.

SBA March 27, 2010

Most funny! I suspect the influential tweeters have you on their wanted list — you are a 'top commentator' and someone has to pay!
But seriously, I just retweeted and no problem. What error did you get when you tried? Meanwhile you can use the short url "http://bit.ly/cPNWwo" and go about it the old-fashioned way… thanks.
Update: OH! I get it now. You pressed the photo of the tweet button within the post! I thought that might trap someone… lol

timethief April 1, 2010

@SBA

You will laugh when you hear this. I clicked the Topsy Retweet Button example in the post and not the actual retweet on the top of the post itself. :D

timethief March 27, 2010

Here's a belly laugh for you as I was reading the article I clicked the retweet button and discovered it wasn't functioning. DUH…

Doug C. March 27, 2010

Ha, I love it. Even laughed a couple times, especially at "…if your name is not 'Used Tires'!'" I'll probably be resourcing this article when the Topsy plugin gets updated for me. The developer said he was going to be making some options to disable the plugin on certain pages.

SBA March 27, 2010

Thanks. I see you have "coder" friends in high places! Nice to have your suggestions in the mix.

Creative Junkie March 26, 2010

I have the tweetmeme plugin and so far, it's still working, but I might check the topsy retweet plugin out as well. I never even heard of it until I read this!

SBA March 27, 2010

Yes, give it a try. Change (even when forced by plugin gremlins) is good. Nice to see you again!

{ 3 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: